David Milne review – One of Canada’s greatest painters? Come off it!

Dulwich Picture Gallery, London
From the glitz of New York’s gilded age to the horror of the trenches, Milne had plenty to work with. So why does our critic prefer his photos?

‘Tediously genteel’ … Billboards, c.1912, by David Milne.

‘Tediously genteel’ … Billboards, c.1912, by David Milne.
Photograph: © The Estate of David Milne

This exhibition of a supposedly “great” Canadian artist who was unsuccessful in his own lifetime and is little-known outside his own country today is called David Milne: Modern Painting. I don’t know what definition of modern painting they used, but it isn’t in any of my books. Milne’s paintings are only modern if by that you mean a wishy-washy vagueness, depressed colours and complete lack of shock. This is the cough of the new, modern art with a yawn.

There is very little sign of development in Milne’s art, and as you navigate his backwoods the monotony of his subdued palette of russets, pale greens, blacks and muddy browns becomes embarrassingly repetitive.

Manhattan via Bloomsbury … Columbus Monument, 1912, by David Milne.

Manhattan via Bloomsbury … Columbus Monument, 1912. Photograph: © The Estate of David Milne

Milne, born in Ontario in 1882, started his career in gilded age New York – already the art capital of the Americas by the 1900s. He painted softly toned scenes of city life that make Manhattan look like a corner of Edwardian Bloomsbury. His dappled studies of women in big hats, people milling about in the Public Library, a couple of cars and some sedate hoardings are timid imitations of the likes of Matisse and Bonnard. Compared with the paintings of George Bellows or photographs of Alfred Stieglitz from the same era, with their powerful sense of a great urban society, Milne’s perceptions of New York are tediously genteel.

He obviously did not feel at home in the metropolis and in 1916 – suffering from what he described as a “nervous heart” – moved to the first of a series of hideaways in the mountains of New York State, before eventually returning to Canada in 1929. From 1916 onwards, the exhibition is dominated by woodland landscapes. In his 1916 watercolour Bishop’s Pond (Reflections), he finds a mirror of his melancholy in the glassy surface of a woodland pool. White, snowy trees become blurred forms of reflected sadness. Yet the exhibition’s attempt to compare his love of reflections with Monet’s waterlilies reveals a loss of perspective. One of Milne’s landscapes might be touching; together, they pall. He seems unable to take his imagination outside a very limited repertoire. In 1929, for instance, he is still brooding miserably on woodland water in the appropriately titled Gray Pool.

Pink Reflections, Bishop’s Pond, 1920, by David Milne.

Reflected sadness … Pink Reflections, Bishop’s Pond, 1920. Photograph: © The Estate of David Milne

When Milne visited the western front in 1919 as an official Canadian artist, the first world war was over and its eerie potholes and trenches gave him plenty of mud and rainwater to brood on. He himself said he was merely a “tourist” among these haunted landscapes. His war art is not especially powerful. Milne was a misery before he visited the trenches and a misery afterwards. Obviously any image of those landscapes of horror is distressing. Yet it is hard to see what Milne’s dappled renditions add to the photographs of the same scenes that are displayed for comparison. The photographs are brutally real, the paintings almost decorative.

That same contrast between the raw reality of the camera and the gentle artifice of Milne’s brush recurs when the woodland photographs he took as part of his research are shown beside his pastoral scenes. I prefer the photos. I have never thought that about a painter before.

This venerable gallery – with its wonderful architecture by John Soane and collection of masterpieces by the likes of Rembrandt and Poussin – is a beautiful place, yet its exhibition programme is turning into an orgy of the second rate. It’s time Dulwich celebrated what it is, an art-historical treasure house, instead of trying to be “modern” and getting lost in some very dreary woods.

Ann Hirsch on the art project that invaded her private life – The Start podcast

Subscribe and review on Apple Podcasts or Acast, and join the discussion on Facebook and Twitter

In 2008, online and performance artist Ann Hirsch started to post videos of herself on YouTube under the pseudonym of Caroline, a self-confessed “hipster college freshman”. The 18-month project, dubbed Scandalishious, explored questions of femininity, sexuality and identity at a time when online presence was little understood.

In the third episode of our new culture podcast about artistic beginnings, Hirsch reveals how Scandalishious became an all-encompassing endeavour: infiltrating her private life, putting her safety at risk and eventually resulting in a breakdown.

Damien Hirst on the break-in that changed his art – The Start podcast

Subscribe and review on Apple Podcasts or Acast, and join the discussion on Facebook and Twitter

In 1985, a young artist in a London squat set to work on a portfolio that would secure him a place at art college. Despite initially struggling to find a medium that suited his artistic expression, Damien Hirst soon found inspiration from an unlikely source, his neighbour, Mr Barnes.

We hear how a man whom Damien never met put into motion the artist’s first forays into sculpture, transformed his view on conceptual art and, ultimately, changed the way he makes it – even to this day.

The Big Burns Supper – in pictures

[unable to retrieve full-text content]

Hitchcock, Hepburn and Dirty Harry: vintage movie posters – in pictures

Original movie posters remain one of the most vibrant sectors of the cultural antiques trade. Produced for classic films including Psycho, Roman Holiday and The Italian Job, these original Hollywood posters from online marketplace AbeBooks are all priced in excess of £1,000 due to their age, scarcity, condition, and cultural and artistic significance

Bristol’s once troubled Arnolfini gallery starts to pull in the crowds

On a midweek lunchtime approaching Christmas, more than 300 visitors are in the busy, buzzy Arnolfini gallery in Bristol. Around a dozen people are rooted to the spot reading Grayson Perry’s social media tapestry Red Carpet; downstairs, the cafe and giftshop are packed.

It’s a far cry from a busted arts organisation, one that was judged so troubled that in June it was removed from the national portfolio of Arts Council England.

The main reason the Arnolfini is busy is that it is staging Perry’s self-fulfillingly titled The Most Popular Art Exhibition Ever! It was first shown at the Serpentine in London, where there were queues to get in.

Claire Doherty, the Arnolfini’s new director, approached Perry about staging it before she formally started in August. She recognised she needed a big-bang moment, a catalyst for the future. It was even before the bombshell day on 27 June when the gallery was removed from the national portfolio.

In an interview with the Guardian, Doherty chose her words carefully about the day. “The decision was made. I think it is really challenging … but it was made on the basis that the financial model was not perceived to be viable by the Arts Council.

The Arnolfini ‘should be an engine, with the heat going out, rather than coming in’

The Arnolfini ‘should be an engine, with the heat going out, rather than coming in’ Photograph: Ben Birchall/PA

“My priority has been to come and look at the organisation and devise a financial model that is viable, and it is absolutely critical going forward. That involves also rethinking the Arnolfini in terms of its future vision.

“One of the reasons I took the job was that I was ready for rethinking what an arts organisation with this history, and this reputation, could be for the future,” Doherty said.

In the art world, Doherty is seen as the right person for the job. Innovative and dynamic, for 15 years she ran the internationally respected arts producers Situations, a company she founded.

It became known for ambitious, thrilling site-specific work in unusual places, whether a gold rush on Folkestone beach, or Theaster Gates’s 24 days of sound and performance at Bristol’s Temple Church. It was also instrumental in rewriting Plymouth’s public art policy.

Doherty is part of a generation of arts leaders looking at the role of arts organisations in a different way, in that they are not just showcases. They also need to have a strong social purpose and be a resource for the community – “we should be thinking of them as playing a role in people’s lives”.

She describes the Arnolfini as an arts centre, and her vision for the future includes showing live art, dance, performance and music as well as internationally important visual art: “But it also has to use its resources, its building, its knowledge, its expertise, its networks for the greater benefit of the city.”

The Arnolfini “should be an engine, with the heat going out, rather than coming in”.

The gallery, in a converted 19th-century warehouse on the city’s harbourside, was founded in 1961. However, in recent years, not enough people were bothering to visit it and it was mired in financial troubles. It asked for extra money from the Arts Council, which is never a good sign.

Claire Doherty, the new director of the Arnolfini arts centre and gallery in Bristol.

Claire Doherty, the new director of the Arnolfini arts centre and gallery in Bristol. Photograph: Adrian Sherratt for the Guardian

The council instead withdrew the Arnolfini’s annual £750,000 funding and removed it from its portfolio. It said the gallery was not viable in its current model. Sir Nicholas Serota, the Arts Council chairman, said it could not go on “staunching losses”.

But he also expressed great faith in Doherty, and the money still exists in that £3.3m over four years was set aside “to invest in a bold new future for visual arts in Bristol for the long term”. Godfrey Worsdale, director of the Henry Moore Foundation, and James Lingwood, co-director of Artangel, were asked to lead a review “addressing the future of the visual arts in Bristol”. Their report is expected in the new year.

“I’m getting on with renewing the business model of the Arnolfini, making sure that the organisation is revitalised, there is a solid business model, and that it is ready for the future,” Doherty said. “I’m not making any assumptions about the outcome of that review.”

Important changes to the physical space to make it more welcoming were an early priority. Previously, “it was quiet, in every meaning of the term. There was not a sense of dynamism or energy in the building.

“As soon as you step in the building, you should have a sense that you are in an arts organisation and want to hang out here, and want to be here.”

New windows are letting in light and visitors to the bar and cafe can now see the harbourside. The Perry show has proved the perfect one for a new chapter in the Arnolfini’s history, with more than 180,000 visitors estimated to have visited across the run.

Visitors admire Grayson Perry’s pink motorbike teddy bear pilgrimage at the Arnolfini

Visitors admire Grayson Perry’s pink motorbike teddy bear pilgrimage at the Arnolfini Photograph: Richard Baker/In Pictures via Getty Images

“The fantastic thing has been the real diversity of audience in terms of age,” said Doherty. “We’ve had teenagers coming after school … and the amount of time people are spending, often at least a couple of hours.”

Doherty has undertaken a mass consultation exercise on what the future of the organisation should be, ripping up the rule book. She has had coffees with more people than she can count, she says, among them artists, volunteers, councillors, dancers and other arts bosses.

On the front window is a text commissioned from Edson Burton called Imagine New Rules, a provocation for new ideas. Doherty said they had received more than 2,000 submissions about what the new Arnolfini should be.

What the future Arnolfini will be remains to be seen. The Perry show closed on Christmas Eve and, remarkably, no programming for 2018 has been announced.

That is either worrying, or exciting. Doherty hopes it is exciting, and stresses that “international exhibitions will continue to be at the heart of what we do”. This year, though, will be one of transition. “Trialling new ways of programming with different kinds of partners, ensuring that the changes I want to make have time and space to take root so that we grow the new Arnolfini on solid ground.”